Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club

Nestled in the heart of Beaver Dam, Wisconsin, Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club offers a classic American steakhouse experience with a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like a cherished local tradition. Renowned for its expertly prepared Black Angus steaks and hearty traditional dinners, this restaurant is a go-to destination for those craving rich, flavorful fare served with genuine Midwestern hospitality.

The menu at Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club reads like a love letter to steak lovers and comfort food enthusiasts alike. Dishes such as the prime rib selections—including the impressive 32 oz Big Joe cut—are a definite highlight, cooked to perfection and accompanied by crowd-pleasers like baked potatoes loaded with sour cream, or their signature rib eye steak fries. Fans of seafood will appreciate the rich, creamy clam chowder, while the Loaded Mushroom Soup offers a hearty and savory start to any meal. The traditional supper club offerings—broasted chicken, pork chops, and meaty BBQ back ribs—bring homestyle flavors to the table, satisfying the soul as much as the appetite.

What truly sets Cantafio's Buckhorn apart is not just the food, but the overall dining experience. Guests frequently praise the attentive and friendly staff who make each visit feel personal and special. One satisfied diner described the service as “simply outstanding,” highlighting the attentive pouring of drinks and warm hospitality that keeps tables buzzing with happy conversation. The owner, Joe, is known to be present in the kitchen, personally ensuring the quality and consistency that guests have come to love.

The ambience complements the hearty cuisine—classic supper club charm with well-kept, inviting interiors that feel both nostalgic and carefully maintained. As one reviewer noted, the spotless and thoughtfully arranged dining area gives the sense that everything is fresh and prepared just for you, contributing to a memorable and comfortable outing.

Beyond the food and service, Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club carries a deeper significance in the community, embodying values of patriotism and support for military families. This adds an emotional layer to every meal, creating a space where guests not only enjoy exceptional food but also connect with a business that reflects sincerity and heartfelt dedication.

Whether you’re stopping by for the iconic Boatload of Cheese N Crackers, indulging in a perfectly grilled filet mignon, or savoring a classic French dip sandwich with fries, Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club delivers a dining experience steeped in tradition, flavor, and heartfelt Midwestern charm. It’s a place where every bite tells a story, and every visit feels like coming home.

For a taste of Beaver Dam’s beloved supper club scene, call +1 920-885-9984 or visit N8802 Co Rd A, and prepare to enjoy a memorable meal full of bold flavors and rich traditions.